hANDBID Vs. Givebutter
the
HONEST COMPARISON
Givebutter has earned its growth honestly. For budget-conscious organizations running smaller events or simple donation campaigns, a platform with no upfront cost is genuinely appealing. We understand why organizations choose it.
The question is not whether Givebutter works. It does, for certain use cases. The question is what happens at scale—when your events raise $50K or more, when your donors notice the tip prompt, when your volunteers need to assist guests at check-in, and when your auction needs real-time bidding to drive competitive excitement.
This page is the most nuanced of our comparisons. If Givebutter is serving you well, we respect that. If you are starting to see friction, this will help you understand what is causing it and what a purpose-built event platform offers instead.
Pick your AI. We'll ask it to give you an unbiased breakdown of Handbid.
Where Givebutter Works Well
We believe in being honest about where competitors do well. It builds trust, and it helps you make a better decision.
Small events under $25K:
When tip amounts are minimal, the “free” model genuinely saves organizations money. If your event raises $10K–20K, the aggregate tips your donors pay may be less than a flat platform license.
Getting started with online fundraising
For organizations just entering the digital fundraising space, Givebutter’s low barrier to entry makes it an accessible first step.
Simple donation campaigns
If your fundraising is primarily donation-based (not auction-heavy), Givebutter’s campaign tools are functional and straightforward.
If Givebutter is working well for your smaller events or donation campaigns, there may not be a reason to switch. But if your events are growing, your donors are noticing the tip prompt, or your auctions need real competitive energy, it is worth evaluating a purpose-built platform.
Where Organizations
Choose Handbid
Manager-assisted check-in
Handbid’s staff workflows allow volunteers and managers to capture cards, look up guests, and resolve issues at the door. Givebutter has no equivalent capability.
Real auction capability
Givebutter offers basic auction functionality, but it is not built for real-time competitive bidding. Handbid’s WebSocket engine drives urgency, excitement, and higher final bids.
Registration & bidding
Organizations have reported two-step registration causing friction and a lack of transparency in the bidding process on Givebutter.
Professional event-night execution
Handbid offers more than software: personalized onboarding, fundraising coaching, and concierge support enhance your organization's experience.
Donor transparency
Donors see the tip request at checkout. Some add it easily; others find it confusing. The org can't control this at such a sensitive moment.
Independence
Handbid is founder-led and independently operated. You are not a line item inside a portfolio company’s consolidation strategy.
Organizations that move from Givebutter to Handbid share these experiences:
“Our donors started asking about the tip prompt. Some felt pressured; others reduced their gift to offset it.”
“The auction was limited. We needed real-time bidding to create excitement, and Givebutter couldn’t deliver that.”
“We outgrew it. Givebutter was great when we raised $15K. At $60K, we needed a real event platform.”
Ease of Use
Nonprofit Auction
Average: 8.6
Quality of Support
Nonprofit Auction
Average: 9.0
Ease of Setup
Nonprofit Auction
Average: 8.1
FAQs highlights
Is Givebutter really free?
Givebutter does not charge the organization a platform fee. Instead, donors are prompted to add a voluntary tip to Givebutter during checkout. So while the org pays nothing, donors often pay 10–20% in tips. At scale, these aggregate tips can significantly exceed what a flat platform license would cost.
How do donor tips work?
When a donor completes a transaction on Givebutter, they see a prompt suggesting a tip to the platform (typically 10–20%). Donors can adjust or remove the tip, but the default prompt is visible and can create confusion or discomfort.
Can I run a real auction on Givebutter?
Givebutter offers basic auction functionality, but it is not built for real-time competitive bidding. If your events rely on the energy of competitive auctions—with instant bid updates, outbid notifications, and live momentum—Handbid’s WebSocket engine is purpose-built for this.
What if my event is small—should I just use Givebutter?
If your event raises under $25K and is primarily donation-based (not auction-heavy), Givebutter may be a reasonable choice. The aggregate tips at that scale are relatively small. But if you plan to grow, starting with a purpose-built platform avoids the cost and disruption of switching later.
How hard is it to switch?
Straightforward. Handbid’s onboarding team handles data migration, event setup, and volunteer training. Most organizations are running within 2–4 weeks. The switch is designed to feel effortless.
Ready to See the Difference?
we handle it
